Humza Yousaf says deal with Greens ‘has served its purpose’ and ‘balance has shifted’ – UK politics live | Politics

Yousaf says deal with Greens ‘has served its purpose’ and in future the two party will cooperate, but less formally

Yousaf says as leader of the government he has to decide how best it can make changes.

For almost three years the SNP had done that throught its agreement with the Scottish Greens. That deal has “undoubtedly” delivered some successes.

But he says, in almost any walk of life, cooperation is a trade-off.

He says, when he said the deal was worth its weight in gold, he meant it.

But he says that is no longer the case. He goes on:

The balance has shifted. The Bute House agreement was intended to provide stability to the Scottish government. And it’s made possible a number of achievements. But it has served its purpose.

Yousaf says the deal was no longer providing stability in parliament.

He says he has told the Scottish Greens he is terminating it with immediate effect.

In the future, the two parties will still cooperate, but in a less formal way, he says.

Share

Key events

‘Quite the opposite. It shows leadership’ – Yousaf rejects claim U-turn on continuing pact with Green shows he’s weak

Q: Does this U-turn show you are weak? [This is the argument the Scottish Tories are making – see 9.54am.]

Yousaf replied:

Quite the opposite. It shows leadership.

As the leader of the government, leader of the party that elected me, I’ve got to make sure I do what’s in the best interest of Scotland.

Share

Q: On Tuesday you were saying you hoped members of the Scottish Greens would vote to continue the Bute House agreement. What changed in 48 hours?

Yousaf says he had to consider this matter in private. He repeats the point about being proud of what the BHA achieved, but he says he felt it had served its purpose.

The deal was a trade-off. For the SNP, the benefit was stability in government. That was no longer being offered, he says.

He says it is now time for all opposition parties to step up. They can’t just “snipe from the sidelines”, he says.

Share

Yousaf is now taking questions. He says he has not got long, because he has to prepare for first minister’s questions at noon.

He thanks Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater for their work in government.

In the future, the SNP and the Scottish Greens will cooperate issue by issue, he says.

Share

Yousaf says the SNP will now govern as a minority government.

But this will mark a “new beginning” for the administration, he says.

I have a clear policy agenda that I wish to take forward, one that centres around growing our economy and supporting businesses, improving our NHS, tackling poverty and child poverty in particular, helping households during Westminster’s cost of living crisis, standing up for the rights of everyone in Scotland, especially our most marginalised communities and for the avoidance of any doubt, tackling the climate emergency.

Share

Yousaf says deal with Greens ‘has served its purpose’ and in future the two party will cooperate, but less formally

Yousaf says as leader of the government he has to decide how best it can make changes.

For almost three years the SNP had done that throught its agreement with the Scottish Greens. That deal has “undoubtedly” delivered some successes.

But he says, in almost any walk of life, cooperation is a trade-off.

He says, when he said the deal was worth its weight in gold, he meant it.

But he says that is no longer the case. He goes on:

The balance has shifted. The Bute House agreement was intended to provide stability to the Scottish government. And it’s made possible a number of achievements. But it has served its purpose.

Yousaf says the deal was no longer providing stability in parliament.

He says he has told the Scottish Greens he is terminating it with immediate effect.

In the future, the two parties will still cooperate, but in a less formal way, he says.

Share

Humza Yousaf holds press conference

Humza Yousaf, the SNP leader and Scottish first minister, is holding a press conference now.

He says he has been in the post for little more than a year.

When he took over, he said he was committed to ensuring every family had equality of opportunity, and to promoting measures to encourage growth, and to improve well being.

He says his policies are making a difference.

We are investing record [sums in the NHS], ensuring it can employ record numbers of staff delivering the best performing A&E units in UK. We are, of course, the only part of the UK to avoid strike action in NHS. I’ve delivered the council tax freeze this year in every local authority, helping families …

And last week we approved plans for Europe’s largest floating offshore wind farm. These are just some of the actions that are making Scotland a better country.

Share

The SNP MP Joanna Cherry has welcomed the end of the pact with the Scottish Greens. She posted these on X about an hour ago. Cherry is an outspoken gender critical feminist who has always been particularly critical of the Scottish Greens on trans issues.

If true this would be excellent news. The Scottish Greens have brought nothing transformative to the table on climate change that was actually viable, their science denying response to the #CassReport was disgraceful & their identity politics are toxic. https://t.co/pfR7Ix0Mic

— Joanna Cherry KC (@joannaccherry) April 25, 2024

If true this would be excellent news. The Scottish Greens have brought nothing transformative to the table on climate change that was actually viable, their science denying response to the #CassReport was disgraceful & their identity politics are toxic.

The ending of the Bute House agreement is a huge opportunity for the SNP to reset our agenda in government. Out with identity politics & virtue signalling. In with policies to tackle the bread & butter issues that our constituents bring up on the doorsteps.

Share

Here is a clip of Humza Yousaf saying just two days ago he wanted the pact with the Scottish Greens to continue.

Share

Scottish Tories claim end of power-sharing deal with Greens is ‘utter humiliation’ for Yousaf

The Tories are claiming the end of the pact with the Scottish Greens is “an utter humiliation” for Humza Yousaf. The Scottish Conservative chair, Craig Hoy, has put out this statement.

The collapse of this toxic coalition is an utter humiliation for Humza Yousaf, who hailed it as ‘worth its weight in gold’ and continued to back it to the hilt right until the end.

The first minister’s judgment is so poor that he couldn’t see what a malign influence the anti-growth Greens have been in government and his authority so weak that he was bounced into this U-turn by his own MSPs.

It beggars belief that the Greens were invited into government in the first place – but even more astonishing that Humza Yousaf allowed them to call the shots on issues like abandoning oil and gas, further delays to dualling the A9 and A96, devastating fishing curbs and gender ideology.

Humza Yousaf’s year as SNP leader has been a disastrous mix of scandals, infighting and policy U-turns. The collapse of the power-sharing pact he staked his reputation on is not just humiliating, it highlights once again how inept and out his depth he is.

Share

Humza Yousaf, the SNP leader and Scottish first minister, is due to hold a press conference shortly.

Share

This is from Ash Regan, an MSP who defected from the SNP to Alba after coming third in the SNP leadership contest last year. She tabled a no confidence motion in Patrick Harvie, the Scottish Green co-leader and, until this morning, a Scottish government minister, earlier this week. She was arguing that Harvie should resign from the government because of his failure to fully support the Cass review saying puberty blockers and cross-sex hormones should not be given to children wanting to change gender.

48 hours ago I put a motion of no confidence in against Patrick Harvie, today the Government have agreed.

I am glad to see the extremely unpopular politics of the greens have been abandoned and the SNP have found a backbone.

— Ash Regan MSP (@AshReganALBA) April 25, 2024

48 hours ago I put a motion of no confidence in against Patrick Harvie, today the Government have agreed.

I am glad to see the extremely unpopular politics of the greens have been abandoned and the SNP have found a backbone.

The former SNP MSP Joan McAlpine has posted a message on X suggesting Humza Yousaf may have decided to ditch the pact with the Scottish Greens because he realised many SNP MPs wanted to support the Regan no confidence motion.

Wouldn’t be surprised if a significant number of SNP MSPs told whips they planned to support Ash’s motion of NC in the increasingly extremist Mr Harvie. Might explain Humza Yousaf’s reverse ferret on Bute House Agreement with Greens today https://t.co/sMeFiWQy1d

— Joan McAlpine (@JoanMcAlpine) April 25, 2024

Wouldn’t be surprised if a significant number of SNP MSPs told whips they planned to support Ash’s motion of NC in the increasingly extremist Mr Harvie. Might explain Humza Yousaf’s reverse ferret on Bute House Agreement with Greens today

Although the Scottish government’s decision last week to drop emissions targets for 2030 is the primary reason for the SNP/Scottish Greens pact collapsing, the Cass report, and transgender policy generally, are also important factors.

The Scottish Greens are much more strongly committed to trans rights than any other party in the UK. They pushed Nicola Sturgeon to pass the gender recognition reform bill that was ultimately blocked by Westminster (one of various factors contributing to Sturgeon’s loss of authority before she resigned), and Green MSPs were wanted the SNP to be more critical of the Cass findings.

Share

Scottish Greens describe SNP’s decision to unilaterally end power-sharing deal as ‘act of political cowardice’

Lorna Slater, one of the co-leaders of the Scottish Greens, has confirmed that the power-sharing agreement with the SNP is over.

In a statement, she said the SNP’s decision to end the deal, without allowing party members a say, was ‘an act of political cowardice”.

Share

These are from Hamish Morrison, a reporter on the National, the pro-independence paper in Scotland.

A Green source texts calling for Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater to quit as leaders. Also a stinging broadside about Ross Greer pic.twitter.com/atbrHat2rd

— Hamish Morrison (@HMorrison97) April 25, 2024

It will be interesting to see how Humza Yousaf spins his decision to kick the Greens out of government after saying literally less than 24 hours ago SNP members didn’t want or need a vote on the BHA. Was that because he’d already decided to bin them?

— Hamish Morrison (@HMorrison97) April 25, 2024

The BHA is the Bute House agreement.

The National is running a live blog on the break-up of the power-sharing agreement.

(Neither side called it a coalition, although in practice that is what it was.)

Share

The powersharing deal between the SNP and Scottish Greens at Holyrood has been brought to an end, PA Media is reporting.

Share

Humza Yousaf reportedly abandons power-sharing agreement with Scottish Greens

Good morning. Humza Yousaf, Scotland’s first minister, has reportedly abandoned the SNP’s power-sharing agreement with the Scottish Greens. He called an emergency meeting of his cabinet this morning, and the co-leaders of the Scottish Greens, Lorna Slater and Patrick Harvie, who were ministers, were seen leaving soon afterwards. Yousaf reportedly sacked them, and plans to run a minority administration.

Yousaf has not publicly confirmed this yet, but a press conference is expected later.

This is from PA Media with some background.

The Greens were angered when the Scottish net zero Secretary Mairi McAllan announced last week the Scottish government was to ditch a key climate change target.

That, combined with the decision to pause the use of puberty blockers for new patients attending the only Scottish gender identity clinic for children in Glasgow, resulted in the Greens saying last week that they would have a vote on the future of the powersharing deal.

That vote is expected to take place later on in May – but it now appears the SNP could end the Bute House Agreement before that.

The deal, which was signed in 2021 and is named after the official residence of the Scottish first minister in Edinburgh, brought the Green party into government for the first time anywhere in the UK.

It gave the SNP a majority at Holyrood when the votes of its MSPs were combined with those of the seven Greens members, and also made Greens co-leaders Patrick Harvie and Lorna Slater junior ministers in the Scottish government.

Without it the SNP would need to operate as a minority administration at Holyrood.

High-profile figures in the SNP, such as former leadership candidate Kate Forbes and party stalwart Fergus Ewing, have previously called for the deal to be ended.

We will have more on this as the situation develops.

Here is the agenda for the day.

9am: Louise Haigh, the shadow transport secretary, gives a speech setting out details of Labour’s plans to nationalise the rail network.

9.30am: The ONS publishes crime figures for England and Wales.

9.45am: Angela van den Bogerd, the former Post Office people services director, gives evidence to the Post Office Horizon inquiry. She is seen as one of the most Post Office executives to give evidence so far because of the key role she played in defending the prosecutions of post officer operators.

11am: An announcement is expected in the Lords confirming that the safety of Rwanda (asylum and immigration) bill has received royal assent.

11.30am: Downing Street holds a lobby briefing.

Lunchtime: James Cleverly, the home secretary, is speaking at a press gallery lunch at Westminster.

Early afternoon: Keir Starmer is on a visit to a rail manufacturing plan in the north-east of England.

Also, David Cameron, the foreign secretary, is in Mongolia on the latest stage of his trip to Central Asia.

If you want to contact me, do use the “send us a message” feature. You’ll see it just below the byline – on the left of the screen, if you are reading on a laptop or a desktop. This is for people who want to message me directly. I find it very useful when people message to point out errors (even typos – no mistake is too small to correct). Often I find your questions very interesting, too. I can’t promise to reply to them all, but I will try to reply to as many as I can, either in the comments below the line; privately (if you leave an email address and that seems more appropriate); or in the main blog, if I think it is a topic of wide interest.

Share

Updated at